Searching for a good God in the midst of evil

Allison Moore

I quickly skimmed the first chapters of “The Shack” and my worst fears came to life within its pages. How could God allow a little girl be kidnapped and killed in the hands of grown man? 

It was so scary and close to home as a mom of four girls, that every part of my being cried out to God, “Why? Why do such things happen on your watch?” In that moment, I had to admit part of me had doubts about God’s goodness. It’s the part of me that talks back when I pray for the safety of my loved ones. 

Why should you be saved from pain? 
Much better people experience great struggle and tragedy. 
Why are you praying for prevention when you know God doesn’t really do that?

How can we follow an all-powerful God who doesn't seem to intervene when evil men prey on the vulnerable? Although “The Shack” did a decent job of displaying some of God’s character in human terms, the truth can get lost if we use allegory as a source of theology rather than entertainment. When we use anything but God’s Word to explain the world, we will always fall short. 

So why is evil allowed to exist when an all-powerful God is capable of stopping it? 

To understand anything about how God works, we have to look to the Bible to understand who God is. Only when we know who God is and who we are in relationship to Him can we gain insight into how He deals with the sin of this world. 

Who We Are

1. We are sinners. 

Psalm 51:5 says we are sinful from birth. We don’t have to teach toddlers to think about themselves first. We all have the capacity to be selfish, but those who have been sinned against and suffered maltreatment are even more likely to act on their anger in extreme ways (Ecclesiastes 7:7). 

2. We are evil. 

We have often heard it said that people are generally good, but according to Jeremiah 17:9, we are actually evil at heart. We don’t like to think of ourselves that way, but the Bible repeatedly says we're all inclined to sin. 

 3. We have a free will. 

God gave us the ability to choose Him (Isaiah 55:6-7). Since God is all powerful and all knowing, it is hard to reconcile that He does not intervene to prevent bad. But if God stopped all the bad things that happen, we wouldn’t really have free will at all. We’d be like robots. True love can only exist within the context of a choice. God gives us that choice while drawing us to Himself.

True love can only exist within the context of a choice.

Because sin is a reality in the world and we have evil bound up in our hearts, we have to fight against the evil one who seeks to destroy us (Luke 6:45 and 1 Peter 5:8). If we don’t, we’ll be more inclined to perpetuate satan’s lies instead of Jesus’ love.

Who God Is

1. God is a loving Father who made a way for sinners to be saved. 

God refused to leave us alone in our sinful state. He provided a way for all who believe in Him to not suffer the consequences of sin (Romans 5:8). In His mercy, He wishes for all to come to repentance, which is why he does not intervene and “zap” us when we sin. 

God is patient (Numbers 14:18). We should not mistake His lenience for weakness or be frustrated with His temporary lack of action. In God’s mercy, He postpones judgment to give us time for repentance.

2. God is a promise keeper who will judge sin. 

Jesus is the final judge, jury, and executioner. In Romans 12:19, the Lord says He will avenge evil. This isn’t some pansy, slap-on-the-wrist sort of punishment but eternal torment (Revelation 21:8). Our infinitely powerful God will exact judgment on evil and punish the unrepentant more severely than we could ever imagine. 

3. God is our redeemer. 

God can take the most broken stories and bring life and hope from them in incredible ways. The people we admire most in this life are the ones who have scars from the battles they’ve fought and won by trusting in God. When we allow God to heal our hurts, we gain a depth of strength and beauty only He can provide (Isaiah 61:3).

While some people struggle with the existence of an all-powerful God when evil appears to flourish, others just want to stump Christians with “gotcha” questions. Don’t be dismayed when this happens. There will always be questions we can’t fully answer, and that is a good thing. 

Take comfort in knowing mankind will never outsmart God. We have an infinite God whose ways are much higher than ours (Isaiah 55:9). We won’t understand everything this side of heaven. We are not meant to know everything, but to embrace the questions that motivate us to dig a little deeper into who God is and who He created us to be (1 Corinthians 13:12). 

God is big enough to handle our questions, and we’ll find peace when we seek Him (Jeremiah 29:13).

Related Content

to Discover More


Think God won't understand what you're going through?

parenting suffering characteristics of god

I like to think that I have a great relationship with my teenage daughter. We talk through things, we laugh t... read more

Read Article


Our God is a present father

fatherhood characteristics of god

You know that feeling when you are with someone you love? Whether it be a best friend, a parent, spouse, or f... read more

Read Article


Why you can trust your heavenly Father’s discipline

discipline characteristics of god

I don’t need to explain to my kids when I get out of the Chick-fil-A drive before getting them a t... read more

Read Article


How to heal the broken lens abusive fathers leave

abuse fatherhood forgiveness characteristics of god

“Abuse from my earthly father makes it hard for me to see any father as good, including God.” If... read more

Read Article


God is the one dad who will never leave you

fatherhood children parenting characteristics of god

If you’ve been around church for any length of time you have probably heard this: “God won’... read more

Read Article


God's not fair and that's a good thing

forgiveness justice characteristics of god

Even from an early age, we know when something is unfair. "He got 10 more minutes on the swing!"  "She... read more

Read Article


The Father's Discipline

From No Ordinary Father

Sep 24, 2018

discipline fatherhood characteristics of god following jesus

The word "discipline" carries negative associations for many people. But our Heavenly Father is perfect, and ... read more

Watch Sermon


The Ultimate Aim of Your Adoption

From No Ordinary Father

Oct 8, 2018

fatherhood joy characteristics of god adoption

What if we don't have to choose between our enjoyment and God's glory? Pastor John Piper explores the... read more

Watch Sermon


Gives You A Name

From No Ordinary Father

Sep 17, 2018

fatherhood purpose characteristics of god kingdommentality

What does it mean for God to name us His sons and daughters? Kaleb White explains that as adopted children, w... read more

Watch Sermon


The Principle of Provision

From No Ordinary Father

Oct 1, 2018

fatherhood provision grace characteristics of god following jesus

Every believer has the right to access God's abundant provision in Jesus. Brad Cooper discusses the Old T... read more

Watch Sermon

Sermon Series

No Ordinary Father

Sep 9, 2018 - Oct 7, 2018

fatherhood characteristics of god following jesus

How do you see God? To some, He’s a judge or granter of wishes. To others, He’s more of a distant... read more

Read Sermon Series


Hallowed Be Thy Name

From Teach Us to Pray

Jan 11, 2020

prayer characteristics of god

When Jesus teaches us to pray, "hallowed be thy name," He reminds us how special it is to call God by name. T... read more

Watch Sermon

What's happening at NewSpring Church?

  • Need to Know: Weekly email to keep you informed about what's happening at NewSpring
  • Fuse News: Email for Fuse parents sent on the first Monday of the month
  • KidSpring Scoop: Email sent at the beginning of each series to give you the scoop on what's happening in KidSpring
  • Read My Bible: Daily devotional sent via text from 6-7am