The best question to ask before disciplining your kids

Sara Alexander

As parents, the challenge we face when it comes to disciplining our children isn’t a lack of information. No generation of parents has ever experienced the bombardment of expert opinions and discussion groups as our generation has. The problem is finding what works for your family and consistently living it out.

So how do we figure out what works? This simple question has made a huge difference in the way my husband and I view discipline in our home: “Is my child acting sinful or is she simply acting like a child?”

What Sinfulness Looks Like

You have to run into the grocery store even though it's already nap time. You are zipping up and down the aisles doing your best to keep your tired toddler entertained, but things take a turn for the worse and your child starts swinging his fists and kicking his legs in an effort to hurt you.

The childish behavior (fussing and whining due to needing a nap) has turned into sinful behavior (hitting and kicking out of anger). You might be tempted to ignore the bad behavior, but you can’t excuse their anger simply because it's past nap time.

Our children’s sin needs to be disciplined so they can learn to control themselves in the future. Proverbs 29:15 says, “The rod and reproof give wisdom, but a child left to himself brings shame to his mother.”

We are all born sinful, even our kids. No one had to teach them how to rebel or act selfishly. But if we want our kids to be able to walk in wisdom as adults, we have to train their hearts and minds by addressing their sin as children.

What Childishness Looks Like

Shortly after we moved into our current home, I found numerous screwdriver holes in the wall by our front door, and immediately my temper flared. The crafty culprit was our youngest child who was just 3 at the time. I knew it was important to address the issue right away, but I was mad and I didn’t want to say anything I would regret later.

As I cooled down, I had to ask: “Did Wyatt know it was wrong to put holes in the wall or was he simply imitating what he’d seen that week as we had moved into our home?”

After a few deep breaths and silent prayers, I realized that he was not acting out of disobedience. His action was based on wanting to be like his daddy who is great at fixing things around the house. Wyatt was quite proud of what he had done to “help Mommy.”

My anger deflated once I took the time to evaluate if my child was acting childish or sinful. By establishing the heart or motive behind his behavior, I was able to firmly and lovingly tell my young contractor that daddy's tools are off limits. This childish mistake provided me with a powerful moment to set a boundary for my child’s own safety and for the safety of our home.  

By asking if our child’s negative behavior is sinful or childish, we can know the best way to reach our child’s heart and shape his behavior.

The Bible teaches us as followers of Jesus to discipline our child just as our Heavenly Father disciplines us (Hebrews 12:5-11). By asking if our child’s negative behavior is sinful or childish, we can know the best way to reach our child’s heart and shape his behavior.

Related Content

to Discover More


How to know when to speak as the parent and when to love like a friend

family children parenting kids following jesus

As my daughter ages, it’s genuinely exciting to watch her mature and start looking more like an adult than a ... read more

Read Article


How to fight back when greed grabs hold of your kids at Christmas

children christmas greed parenting kids following jesus

I don’t know about you, but this time of year seems to create little gimmie monsters of our normal, mostly ki... read more

Read Article


How to win the mommy wars

family children parenting mothers

“Your kids go to public school?” The judgment dripped out of her mouth as she made a face that looked like s... read more

Read Article


Five ways to put God first with your kids

children parenting following jesus put god first

The kids had been out of school for several days and too much of their vacation was being spent in front of a... read more

Read Article


​Am I a failure if my child doesn’t follow Jesus?

family children faith parenting college

It’s painful to watch someone you love say “no” to Jesus or walk away from the church. Seeing a child settle ... read more

Read Article


“Thank you for giving me up for adoption": A conversation with Clayton King

family children parenting abortion adoption

For National Adoption Awareness Month, Clayton King sat down for a wide-ranging conversation on Facebook Live... read more

Watch Article


How to ease back-to-school anxiety

family students children kids

Every summer, I say the same things and hear them echoed by friends and family: “This summer has flown by.” “... read more

Read Article


When fathers and daughters stop talking

family fatherhood children parenting

Have you ever been wrong about something for 23 years? I have. Until the age of 23, when people would tell ... read more

Read Article

What's happening at NewSpring Church?

  • Need to Know: Weekly email to keep you informed about what's happening at NewSpring
  • Fuse News: Email for Fuse parents sent on the first Monday of the month
  • KidSpring Scoop:Email sent each Friday with the scoop on what's happening in KidSpring.
  • Read My Bible: Daily devotional sent via text from 6-7am