How can I tell if it’s God testing me or Satan tempting me?

Hunter McGee

We are tested every day with temptation to do what we know is wrong. We wonder if it’s a way for God to test us or Satan to defeat us. I’ve often wondered if the reason I can’t keep a job for years to come is because God is testing my faith or because Satan is tempting me to doubt God can provide.

Many people ask the question, “How do I tell the difference between God testing me and Satan tempting me?”

This usually stems from a mindset that it’s not always easy to tell when God is speaking or when someone else is. We have all wondered how we can know we are hearing from God, and often struggle with the thought of it being something He actually told us to do or something we made up. How do we know when to do what is right and what is actually a test to see if we will grow from the experience?

God Allows Us To Be Tempted

The question isn’t only whether we’re being tested or tempted, but how will we respond to the situation. A lot of people would answer this question by saying, “God is never part of anything that tempts you because God will never put something on you that you can’t handle.” But, this just isn’t true. Paul wrote to Christians in Corinth about how God will never let someone be tempted beyond what he or she can bear (1 Corinthians 10:13). God allows us to be tempted, but provides us the ability to resist temptation and a way out of the situation.

One of the main reasons this question is asked is because we don’t want to accept the fact that God allows us to be tempted. Jesus was tempted and made it through. He can identify with your anger, greed, and struggle for provision because He was tempted in every way just like us, yet stood up to it to provide us a way to withstand it and stand firm against it (Hebrews 4:15).

Satan Cannot Tempt Us Without Approval

God rules over everything, even Satan, so everything Satan does has to go through God first. So, maybe God testing and Satan tempting aren’t two separate things at all – maybe they work together. In Job 1:1-22, the dialogue between God and Satan shows Satan asking God for approval before he can act against Job. Sometimes God tests us by allowing Satan to tempt us. Because God knows that He will get glory out of it by making wrong things right, and Satan will fail, God allows us to be tempted.

None of us likes to go through testing and temptation, but God can use them to grow our faith. James 1:2-5 says to consider it a joy whenever we face trials so that we can be mature and complete. When that happens, God will help our faith grow and make us stronger for the next challenge.

Read more about growing your faith and the problem of evil. 

Related Content

to Discover More


Are you trying to man-handle God?

trust faith discipleship following jesus

Thanks to Hollywood, almost everyone knows the story of Moses.  God used him to lead the Israelites out ... read more

Read Article


How to know you have an idol

temptation idolatry following jesus

On my bookshelves in my study in our basement, you will find objects from my travels around the world.  ... read more

Read Article


What every man needs to know about missions

evangelism faith missions following jesus God's will

You weren’t born just to pay bills, grow old, and die. You weren’t just born to get saved, live i... read more

Read Article


Can you prevent your college student from losing her religion?

faith parenting following jesus college

This year, I have both a college freshman and a college senior. They were raised in church, grew up in Sunday... read more

Read Article



From Family Values

Feb 18, 2019

faith following jesus boldmoves

Growth means change. In this message, Clayton King teaches us that making a bold move is how we step into the... read more

Watch Sermon


Seek First

From First

Jan 14, 2019

prayer faith following jesus

Everyone has hopes and dreams. But hope is not a strategy for change. In this message, Brad Cooper encouraged... read more

Watch Sermon


Goodness and Mercy

From Shepherd

July 23, 2018

jesus faith following jesus

You can be certain that God is good, He loves you, He keeps His promises, and that Jesus is alive! You can al... read more

Watch Sermon


Session 3

From Gauntlet 2018

Aug 9, 2018

trust faith following jesus

Jesus' asks His followers to the narrow path, and His teaching is frequently hard to understand. So why d... read more

Watch Sermon


Why we do Fuse

From Vision Weeks

May 3, 2018

jesus relationships faith following jesus

Fuse exists to show you how to love God and live the life He has for you.

Watch Sermon


A Little Faith Goes a Long Way

From Parables

Sep 20, 2018

faith following jesus kingdommentality

Something so small has the potential to grow into something great.

Watch Sermon


Ask Your Father

From Teach Us to Pray

Jan 26, 2020

prayer faith humility following jesus

Our willingness to ask God for anything and about anything changes when we remember the access we have as His... read more

Watch Sermon

What's happening at NewSpring Church?

  • Need to Know: Weekly email to keep you informed about what's happening at NewSpring
  • Fuse News: Email for Fuse parents sent on the first Monday of the month
  • KidSpring Scoop: Email sent at the beginning of each series to give you the scoop on what's happening in KidSpring
  • Read My Bible: Daily devotional sent via text from 6-7am